According to the article, Dispelling Myths About Blocked Websites in School by Tina Barseghian, there are certain myths and criticisms that need to be addressed.
- "Accessing YouTube is not violating the [Act]." I just started teaching Civics in a new school district. To introduce an unit about the U.S. Constitution, I wanted to show a Schoolhouse Rock clip about the Preamble. I was shocked that I couldn't access YouTube with my teacher login. There are so many good educational videos on YouTube. It is a shame that some schools block it.
- "Websites don't have to be blocked for teachers." The act does not mention that websites have to be blocked for teachers. Actually, I fully believe that schools should trust their teachers.
- "Kids need to be taught how to be responsible digital citizens." Blocking websites are like training wheels. They are good for the lower grades, but someday, students need to learn how to use the Internet responsibly. The training wheels need to come off!
Reference:
Barseghian, T. (2011). Dispelling Myths About Blocked Websites in School. Mind Shift. Available from http://mindshift.kqed.org/2011/09/dispelling-myths-about-blocked-websites-in-schools/